Skip to main content
← Back to Blog
Oakes & Fosher in the News

Oppenheimer Ordered to Pay Investor $1.2 Million in Case

October 18, 2018

By Caitlin Nish | January 18, 2013

NEW YORK--An arbitration panel has ordered Oppenheimer & Co. to pay nearly $1.2 million to a Texas investor who accused two of the firm's brokers of excessive trading in his account to generate hefty commissions.

The investor, Lloyd A. Gillespie, claimed the brokers inappropriately concentrated his account in highly speculative stocks, including penny stocks, and occasionally used margin to buy them, according to the ruling from the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority arbitration panel.

Mr. Gillespie further alleged the annual turnover ratio was indicative of churning, or trading the account excessively. Over a roughly two-and-a-half-year period, he claimed, there were more than $551,000 in commissions generated on an approximately $2 million account, according to the documents.

Mr. Gillespie "had always been a conservative investor and didn't want to take a lot of risks with his money, yet they put them in these high-risk stocks," said Bruce Oakes, one of the attorneys who represented him. The brokers then "excessively traded them, which was even worse."

"There wasn't any supervision by Oppenheimer," added Mr. Oakes, a partner at Oakes & Fosher LLC. "They failed miserably in that area."

An Oppenheimer spokesman said the firm "believes it had strong defenses to this action," but declined to comment on the award, noting that the firm hasn't reviewed it.

Mr. Gillespie, in a claim originally filed in 2009, asked the panel for $4 million in compensation from Oppenheimer as well as punitive damages and attorneys' fees. However, he didn't directly name either of his brokers.

Mr. Gillespie also made claims against two other firms where his brokers later worked, but those cases were settled.

The arbitration panel found Oppenheimer liable for roughly $848,000 in compensatory damages, as well as interest, $174,000 in attorneys' fees and $52,000 in costs, but denied the investor's request for punitive damages. As is customary, the panel didn't explain the reasoning for its decision, which was dated Thursday.

The panel further denied the two brokers' requests to have Mr. Gillespie's allegations wiped from their publicly available broker records.

The ruling will "hopefully show brokerage firms like Oppenheimer they have a duty to protect their clients from brokers who want to engage in wrongdoing like churning or excessively trading an account," Mr. Oakes said.

Related Case Results

Oakes & Fosher in the News
April 27, 2017

Madison County Seeks To Recover Investment Losses

Attorneys for Madison County claim that brokerage firm Sterne Agee & Leach of Birmingham, Ala. defrauded the county by selling it inappropriate securities and generating millions of dollars in excessive commissions and fees, according to an amended complaint…

Read More
Oakes & Fosher in the News
April 27, 2017

Couple Wins $922k Arbitration Claim Over Illiquid Real Estate Investments

Couple Wins $922K Arbitration Claim Over Illiquid Real Estate Investments By Bruce Kelly | December 15, 2016 Mid Atlantic Capital Corp., an independent broker-dealer, lost a $922,000 arbitration award on Tuesday to a couple who sued the company over sales of…

Read More
Oakes & Fosher in the News
April 27, 2017

Will New Rules Oust The IRA Scoundrels?

“The Labor Department has set out to purify the sometimes putrid advice people get on investments in their retirement accounts. But will the new rule proposed last week do the trick? The rule says that financial advisers have to put the clients’ interest…

Read More
Oakes & Fosher in the News
January 15, 2020

Elderly Investor Wins $2.6 Million From Indie Firm In FINRA Arbitration

By Vicky Ge Huang | January 8th, 2020 A Finra arbitration panel has ordered National Planning Corp. to pay $2.6 million to an octogenarian customer who bought fraudulent promissory notes, non-traded real estate investment trusts (REITs) and other unsuitable…

Read More
Oakes & Fosher in the News
April 27, 2017

Royal Alliance to pay $1.4 million over nontraded REIT, VA Sales

Royal Alliance to Pay $1.4 million Over Non-Traded REIT, VA Sales By Mason Braswell | July 16, 2015 Royal Alliance Associates Inc., one of four subsidiary broker-dealers of AIG Adviser Group, has been ordered to pay $1.4 million to three retirees over…

Read More
Oakes & Fosher in the News
October 18, 2018

Stifel Nicolaus To Pay $42,000 Award To Investor

Stifel Nicolaus To Pay $42,000 Award To Investor By Diana Barr | April 1, 2011 An investor who lost money more than a year ago in a Ponzi scheme run by a former St. Louis-area broker has been awarded more than $42,000 in damages and fees from Stifel, Nicolaus…

Read More

Do You Suspect Investment Fraud? We Can Help

Contact us today to discuss your situation and begin the process of financial recovery. Consultations are 100% free and confidential.