Skip to main content
← Back to Blog
Oakes & Fosher in the News

Oft-Sanctioned Ex-Broker Kathleen Tarr Loses Expungement Request

April 27, 2017

By Jed Horowitz | March 29, 2017

The same day that an arbitrator last week completed a six-hour hearing on former independent broker Kathleen J. Tarr’s bid to expunge a customer’s complaint about allegedly unsuitable sales of privately-traded REIT sales from her regulatory record, he denied the request.

The decision, published on the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority’s online arbitration award site on Monday, is unusual because Tarr, who accumulated at least 42 customer complaints over her 12-year career at three firms, is challenging them and because Royal Alliance Associates, which employed her for eight years until her discharge in 2010, supported the expungement request, lawyers said.

Also unusual is that the customer, who settled the real estate investment trust case for $25,000 in December, according to Central Registration Depository (CRD) records, persisted in opposing Tarr’s expungement bid.

“The problem is that once a case is settled, few clients want to stick around to oppose expungement, and that lets bad brokers think they can get away with it,” said Bruce Oakes, a St. Louis-based lawyer who represented client Ruby Maddox in the REIT investments settlement and in the expungement hearing.

Oakes, who has successfully challenged four other expungement requests by Tarr, including one documenting a seven-figure award, said few lawyers or clients want to spend time or money on expungement challenges once awards are settled or decided.

“I hope if there are any other cases, other attorneys will fight it even if they are not compensated,” he said. “It’s important for the integrity of the CRD system.”

Paul W. Thomas, a Carlsbad, Calif.-based lawyer who represented Tarr, did not immediately return a call for comment. G. Thomas Fleming, a lawyer at Jones Bell Abbott Fleming & Fitzgerald in Los Angeles who represented Royal Alliance in the Maddox case, also did not return calls for comment.

Tarr’s BrokerCheck record is splotched with large red dots of “notifications” about complaints and employer actions, and the record excludes at least one case that has been expunged. Eleven of the 42 listed cases were settled or resulted in arbitration awards against her, one was closed with no action, 15 were withdrawn or denied, and 11 cases are pending, according to BrokerCheck.

A well-publicized arbitration panel’s decision in 2014 to expunge a complaint from Tarr’s record was vacated at the request of Finra by a federal district court and a California appeals court last year. Finra focused on fairness issues involving arbitrators’ refusal to take testimony from the customer rather than on the broker’s record.

Tarr began her career in 2000 with an almost two-year stint at Credit Suisse First Boston, but her records show no formal customer complaints until 2010. She was discharged from Royal Alliance in July of that year for violating firm policy requiring pre-approval of variable annuity transactions, according to BrokerCheck. She moved her license to SII Investments the day she left Royal, but has not been registered since leaving San Ramon, California-based SII in November 2012.

In an interview with The New York Times in 2014, Tarr said she may some day return to the brokerage business. She also told the paper that she does not feel she ever wronged a client.

Related Case Results

Oakes & Fosher in the News
September 13, 2018

Oakes And Fosher Sues New England Securities For Alleged Failure To Supervise

Tale Of Cheating Planner Teaches Lesson By Jim Gallagher | September 27, 2009 In December 2006, Marge and Clyde Crutcher of Godfrey got a letter from the financial planner managing their life savings: "Dear Marge, By the time you receive this I'll be dead.…

Read More
Oakes & Fosher in the News
January 9, 2020

Oakes & Fosher Attorneys Secure $2.6 Million in Damages For Elderly Investor

The Investor Advocate Law Firm of Oakes & Fosher, LLC, www.oakesfosher.com, a law firm specializing in representing investors in cases against stock brokers and brokerage firms, announced today that a three-member Financial Industry Regulatory Authority…

Read More
Oakes & Fosher in the News
August 28, 2018

Oakes & Fosher Convinces FINRA Arbitrators To Order Trustmont Financial To Pay Client $1 Million In Damages

Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. arbitrators ordered Pennsylvania-based Trustmont Financial Group Inc. to pay a client more than $1 million in damages.

Read More
Oakes & Fosher in the News
October 14, 2022

GPB Capital arbitration awards piling up on wealth managers

By Tobias Salinger | January 25th, 2022 After wealth managers helped sell scandal-plagued private placements to an estimated 4,000 seniors and 13,000 other retail clients, they’re getting hit with a steady stream of arbitration awards. MSC-BD, a brokerage…

Read More
Oakes & Fosher in the News
October 18, 2018

Oppenheimer Ordered to Pay Investor $1.2 Million in Case

Oppenheimer Ordered to Pay Investor $1.2 Million in Case By Caitlin Nish | January 18, 2013 NEW YORK--An arbitration panel has ordered Oppenheimer & Co. to pay nearly $1.2 million to a Texas investor who accused two of the firm's brokers of excessive trading…

Read More
Oakes & Fosher in the News
April 27, 2017

Madison County Seeks To Recover Investment Losses

Attorneys for Madison County claim that brokerage firm Sterne Agee & Leach of Birmingham, Ala. defrauded the county by selling it inappropriate securities and generating millions of dollars in excessive commissions and fees, according to an amended complaint…

Read More

Do You Suspect Investment Fraud? We Can Help

Contact us today to discuss your situation and begin the process of financial recovery. Consultations are 100% free and confidential.